COMPARISON OF ENERGY GELS


0A500px-Gels

Energy gels are a useful component of many endurance runners’ training and racing. In marathon distance racing, energy gels can make an important difference – When to eat Energy Gels in the Marathon.

1 Gel Ingredients

Here is an overview of the major ingredients in gels (see The Science of Energy Gels for more details).

  • Maltodextrin is the most easily digested form of carbohydrate, 36% faster than glucose, making it ideal in a gel. More importantly, Maltodextrin requires far less water to be isotonic than glucose or fructose. Maltodextrin has little or no flavor, even at high concentrations.
  • Glucose is easily digested, but requires 6 times as much water as Maltodextrin to be isotonic. Glucose is about three quarters as sweet as sugar (sucrose).
    • Note that 97% of brown rice syrup is a mixture of maltose, which is 2 glucose molecules and maltotriose which is 3 glucose molecules. For practical purposes it can be considered the same as glucose, though possibly contaminated with arsenic.
  • A little bit of Fructose is useful, as fructose is absorbed via different pathways, increasing the total carbohydrate absorption above what is possible with Maltodextrin alone. However, too much Fructose will cause digestive problems and fructose is absorbed at about a forth the rate of glucose. It also requires the same amount of water as glucose to be isotonic. Fructose is 1.7x as sweet as sugar (sucrose).
  • Sugar is a cheap ingredient and is half glucose and half fructose.
  • Fat can make a gel more palatable and is a useful fuel source at ultramarathon distances.
  • Some protein can provide an additional fuel source and help limit the tendency of your body to cannibalize muscle for fuel.
    • Amino acids may help performance, but the evidence is unclear at the levels provided in most gels.
  • Caffeine is great for improving performance and speeding the absorption of carbohydrate, but too much can upset the stomach.
  • Flavor is important, as you won’t want to take an unpalatable gel. Experiment with different flavors, as different people have different tastes.

2 Overview

This table is ordered by ease of digestion, which is a combination of the science of nutrition, personal experience and the experience of many runners I’ve talked to.

Name Calories Carbs Sugar4 Maltodextrin1 Glucose1 Fructose1 Other Carbs1 Protein Fat Sodium Potassium Caffeine Water to
be Isotonic5
Weight6 Carbs/g Cal/g Ease of digestion
(higher is better)
Recommended for
Hammer Gel 90 23g 2g 21g 1g 1g 0g Trace 0g 20mg 0mg 0mg/25mg/50mg 103ml 33g 0.70 2.73 10 Sensitive Stomachs
Gu 100 25g 5g 20g 0g 5g 0g 0g 0g8 50mg 40mg 0mg/25mg/50mg 175ml 32g 0.78 3.13 8 General Use
Gu Roctane 100 25g 5g 20g 0g 5g 0g 1.7g 0g 125mg 55mg 0mg/35mg 164ml 32g 0.63 3.13 8 Those looking for every advantage
Gu (Peanut Butter) 100 20g 5g 15g 0g 5g 0g 1g 1.5g 65mg 60mg 0mg 201ml 32g 0.78 3.13 7 A less sweet Gu
Vi Endurance 100 23g 6g 17g 6g 0g 0g 0g 1g 10mg 15mg 10mg 168ml 32g 0.72 3.13 7 Fructose malabsorption
Clif Shot (new formula) 100 24g 12g 12g 6g 6g 0g 0g 0g7 90mg 50mg 0mg/25mg/50mg/100mg 292ml 34g 0.71 2.94 6 A Gu Alternative
PowerBar Gel 110 27g 10g 17g 0g 10g 0g 0g 0g7 200mg 20mg 0mg/25mg/50mg 293ml 41g 0.66 2.68 5 Those needing extra electrolytes
Accel Gel 100 20g 13g 7g 4g 9g 0g 5g 0g 115mg 30mg 0mg/20mg 297ml 37g 0.54 2.70 4 Improved Recovery and Ultradistances
Honey Stinger 120 29g 29g 0g 14g 15g 0g 0g 0g 50mg 85mg 0mg/32mg 572ml 37g 0.78 3.24 2 Not Recommended
Chocolate #9 70 15g 13g 0g 3g 10g2 2g 1g 1g 75mg Unknown 0mg 256ml 30g 0.50 2.33 2 Not Generally Recommended
2nd Surge 90 18g 13g 0g 7g3 6g3 5g3 3g 0g 115mg 15mg 100mg 274ml 30g 0.60 3.00 0 Not Recommended

Notes

  • 1 These values are estimates based on the stated nutrition and ingredients.
  • 2Agave nectar varies in its fructose content between 90% and 55%, so this calculation assumes the average of about 75%.
  • 3The unusual nature of the ingredients in 2nd surge makes it harder to estimate the types of carbohydrates included.
  • 4The sugar value includes sucrose, fructose, glucose and other ‘sugars’.
  • 5This is an approximation based on the amount of sugar, Maltodextrin, sodium and potassium, ignoring other ingredients. The water included in the gel is assumed to be the overall weight less the weight of the carbs, fat and protein. See The Science of Energy Gels for details on the isotonic calculations.
  • 6This is the net weight of the gel; generally the packaging added 2-3g to the gels according to my scales.
  • 7The chocolate flavor has 1.5g
  • 8The chocolate flavor has 2g

1 Hammer Gel

Hammer Gel is noteworthy as one of the easiest to digest gels. It is nearly all Maltodextrin dissolved in a greater volume of fluid than other gels. The low level of sugars and electrolytes makes this far easier on the digestive system, and is recommended for runners who have issues with other types of gel. Note the low level of Fructose, which makes the maximum carbohydrate absorption lower than other gels. Therefore use Hammer only if Gu is difficult to digest.
Ingredients (Vanilla): Maltodextrin, Filtered Water, Energy Smart (Grape juice and Rice dextrins), Potassium Sorbate (as a preservative), Vanilla Extract, Citric Acid, Potassium Chloride, Salt, Amino Acids (L-Leucine, L-Alanine, L-Valine, L-Isoleucine).

2 Gu

For marathon distance racing, I prefer Gu over all other gels I’ve tried. It contains 5g of Fructose, with the rest of the calories coming from the easily digested Maltodextrin. I find that Gu can be consumed without any extra water as long as it is taken a bit at a time and mixed with saliva. Some of the flavors can be a little strong, but the ‘plain’ Gu has a light cola flavor.
Ingredients (Vanilla): Maltodextrin, water, fructose, Gu Amino acids (leucine, valine, histidine, isoleucine), potassium and sodium citrate, antioxidants (vitamin E and C),citric acid, calcium carbonate, vanilla, sea salt, preservatives (sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate), fumaric acid, herbal blend (chamomile, kola nut, ginger), pectin.

3 Gu (Peanut Butter)

The peanut butter flavored Gu is different enough to justify its own section. The peanut butter flavor is far less sweet than the regular Gu flavors, but if you like peanut butter it can be a lot more palatable. It also substitutes a little bit of fat and protein for the carbohydrate, as well as having a tiny bit more sodium and potassium. I find this flavor digests particularly well and I’d recommend trying get if you’re a fan of peanut butter. Obviously, if you hate peanut butter or you have a peanut allergy this is not going to work for you.
Ingredients: Maltodextrin, water, fructose, Peanut butter (peanuts, salt), Gu Amino acids (leucine, valine, histidine, isoleucine), potassium and sodium citrate, antioxidants (vitamin E and C), preservatives (sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate), calcium carbonate, sea salt, fumaric acid, calcium chloride, pectin, citric acid, malic acid, herbal blend (chamomile, ginger).

4 Gu Roctane

Roctane is a more expensive variant on Gu, though the price has reduced significantly since its introduction. The main difference is the addition of 1.7g of amino acids, which may help slightly. I’ve not noticed any difference when using it, but if you like Gu and are looking for even a slight advantage, it may be worthwhile. If you are paying hundreds of dollars for a race entry and travel, then the extra cost is minor. If you take 8 gels in a 4-hour marathon, Roctane only adds $4-5 to the cost of the race. Of course, you’ll need to practice with Roctane in your training, so you’ll have to factor that cost in as well.
Ingredients (Blueberry flavor): Maltodextrin, water, fructose, Roctane Amino acids (Histidine, Leucine, Valine, Isoleucine), Ornithine Alpha-ketoglutarate (OKG), sodium citrate, malic acid, citric acid, potassium citrate, natural pomegranate flavor, natural berry flavor, calcium carbonate, sea salt, caffeine, sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate.

5 Vi Endurance

Vi Endurance has no fructose, so it’s ideal for those that suffer from fructose malabsorption. It has a little fat in the form of Medium Chain Triglycerides, as well as some Taurine, which I think are good things, but probably the amount is not significant enough to make much of a difference. There is a little caffeine, intended to increase the carbohydrate absorption rather than to improve performance. I found the Vi Endurance very easy on the stomach and a worthy alternative to Hammer Gel, though it’s only from the manufacturer and so it a little more pricy ($1.64 with shipping.)
Ingredients (Vanilla): Maltodextrin, water, dextrose, Vi Endurance Formula (MCT Oil, Taurine, Glucuronolactone, ornithine alpha-ketoglutarate (OKG), citrulline malate, magnesium aspartate, sodium citrate, potassium aspartate), pure vanilla flavor, potassium sorbate, sea salt, caffeine

6 Clif Shot (new formula)

The new formula Clif Shot uses Maltodextrin like other Gels and is similar to Gu. However, it has slightly more sugar making it a little more difficult to digest. One nice thing about Clif Shots is their ‘litter leash’, which is a thin strip that holds the top to the body of the packet so that you’re less lightly to drop the top. I found in practice that I often break the leash when opening the gels, but the idea is a noble one.
Ingredients (Vanilla): Organic Maltodextrin, Organic Sugar, Water, Natural Flavor, Sea Salt, Potassium Citrate.

7 PowerBar Gel

PowerBar Gel is noteworthy because of its higher sodium content that may help alleviate Hyponatremia and Cramps. I found the flavor stronger than Hammer, Gu or Cliff, but still quite pleasant. The level of fructose is higher than I’d like to see for digestibility. You may need to drink some water near the time you take PowerBar Gel due to the extra electrolytes.
Ingredients (vanilla): Carbohydrate blend (Maltodextrin, fructose), water, electrolytes (sodium chloride, sodium citrate, potassium chloride), natural flavor, citric acid, sodium benzoate and potassium sorbate.

8 Accel Gel

I like the 4:1 carbohydrate to protein ratio of Accel Gel, and I often use it in ultramarathon races. There is more sugar than I would like at 13g and the thin consistency makes it harder to eat slowly and mix with saliva.
Ingredients (Vanilla): Water, Fructose, Sucrose, Whey Protein Isolate and Hydrolysate, Maltodextrin, Glycerin, Natural Flavors, Salt, Ascorbic Acid, Vitamin E Acetate, Soy Lecithin.

9 Honey Stinger

Honey contains only simple sugars rather than the Maltodextrin that other Gels use. This makes Honey Stinger much harder to digest than other Gels, and much sweater. This is the one of the few Gels I’ve tried that has given me digestive problems when taken slowly. I also found the sweetness overpowering and unpleasant, though the honey aftertaste was quite nice. I would not recommend Honey Stinger Gels.
Ingredients (Gold flavor): Honey, Water, Potassium Citrate, Salt, Natural Flavors, Vitamins & Minerals, Niacinamide (Vit B3), Calcium Pantothenate (Vit B5), Pyridoxine, Hydrochloride (Vit B6), Riboflavin (Vit B2), Thiamine Mononitrate (Vit B1), Cyanocobalamin (Vit B12)

10 Chocolate

The only ingredients in this #9 are Agave and Cocoa, and Agave is predominantly fructose (55% fructose to 20% glucose). This amount of Fructose is slow to be absorbed and can be difficult to digest, making it a poor choice for most runners. The Agave makes this gel intensely sweet, which I did not like and the ‘processed with alkali‘ means that most of the antioxidants are destroyed. This gel may be suitable for runners that suffer from a blood sugar drop after taking more conventional gels prior to exercise (see The Science of Energy Gels for more details).
Ingredients: organic agave nectar, cocoa processed with alkali

11 2nd Surge

The ingredients in 2nd Surge are rather grim, with Agave providing Fructose and Brown Rice Syrup providing glucose (as disaccharides and trisaccharides). While this may sound better than simply using all sugar, it’s chemically not an improvement, especially as Brown Rice Syrup has a bitter aftertaste and unfortunately may contain arsenic. I found that 2nd surge was overly sweet, with a slightly bitter undertones and rather gritty in texture. 2nd Surge has a higher dose of Caffeine than most gels. It’s unlikely that you’d want to take a 2nd surge every 30 minutes, but if you did, you’d have 800mg of Caffeine during a four hour marathon, which is rather high. (For a 150 pound/75Kg person, that would be nearly 11mg/Kg, far more than seems prudent.) The ratio of carbohydrate to protein can have some benefits, but it’s a 6:1 ratio, rather than 4:1 which the manufacturer claims is ideal in their Accel Gel. Overall, there seems nothing to recommend these gels.
Ingredients (chocolate flavor): Agave syrup, brown rice syrup, evaporated cane sugar, water, whey protein isolate, glycerin, pea protein isolate, cocoa, natural flavors, green tea extract, d-alpha-tocopheryl, salt, grape, pomegranate, mangosteen, goji berry, blueberry, chokeberry, cranberry, apple and bilberry extracts.

12 Vespa Gel

Main article: Vespa Gel

Vespa Gels claims to improve endurance performance by improving fat burning rather than providing fuel like other gels. The science does not seem to back this up, and they are remarkably expensive ($6.75 each).

Advertisements

Posted on 02/16/2013, in Nutrition. Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: